Google’s Performance Max (PMax) campaigns are redefining how businesses approach advertising. With automation at its core, PMax streamlines campaign management, optimizing ad spend across Search, Display, YouTube, Shopping, and more.
But there’s a downside: it’s a black box.
Without strategic guidance, PMax may default to chasing low-value clicks or cheap conversions—results that don’t necessarily align with your growth goals. This is where advertisers need to step in. By feeding PMax strategic inputs—your one-of-a-kind business goals and first-party data–you can transform it from an efficiency machine into a growth engine for your business.
1. Automation isn’t magic: Why PMax needs human direction
Performance Max is built to simplify campaign management. It’s designed to handle cross-channel advertising seamlessly, using machine learning to optimize bids, placements, and creatives. While this automation can save time, it also comes with a critical challenge: control is limited.
The risks of a Black Box
Without intervention, PMax optimizes for basic metrics like clicks or conversions. While these might look good on a dashboard, they don’t always translate into profitability. Imagine this: PMax prioritizes a low-margin product because it converts well, but this product barely contributes to your bottom line. Without human direction, the algorithm doesn’t see the bigger picture.
“65% of marketers grapple with the lack of granular control in Google PMax” | Source: The State of PPC 2024
Why strategic inputs matter
The role of PPC managers has shifted. Instead of micromanaging campaigns, your job is to steer automation strategically. This means providing PMax with intentional inputs—such as business-specific ROAS targets, segmented data, and budget allocations—that align its decisions with your goals.
The key takeaway is: Automation amplifies what you feed it. Make sure it’s working with data that matters.
Black Box algorithms shine at hitting ROAS targets in the fastest, most efficient way possible. However: Their strategic blindness stuns long-term business growth.
2. Feed PMax smarter data with multi-dimensional segmentation
Before you set your ROAS targets and budgets, you need to ensure the data you’re feeding PMax is as strategic as your goals. Standard , 1-dimensional segmentation—focused solely on clicks or conversions—can handcuff PMax, leading it to chase quick wins rather than driving your broader business objectives.
That’s where multi-dimensional product segmentation comes in.
Why multi-dimensional segmentation works
PMax thrives on data, but not all data is created equal. Multi-dimensional segmentation ensures your campaigns reflect the real-world complexity of your business.
By layering multiple dimensions—like profit margins, seasonality, and stock levels—you equip the algorithm with richer insights, enabling smarter, more strategic optimizations. Here’s why combining dimensions beats a single focus:
- Profitability vs. seasonal demand
A high-margin product might seem like the obvious priority, but what if demand isn’t there? Imagine promoting premium winter jackets in July—it’s a budget sinkhole. By combining margin data with seasonal trends, you can prioritize products that are both profitable and timely. - Seasonality vs. inventory levels
Stockouts are a nightmare—especially when you’re running ads. Take a sporting goods retailer during the summer surge for camping gear. Multi-dimensional segmentation ensures ad spend focuses on in-stock items and aligns with seasonal peaks, maximizing both revenue and customer satisfaction. - Profit margins vs. long-tail potential
PMax often defaults to pushing your bestsellers because of their historical performance. But what about underrepresented, high-margin long-tail items? By layering profit data with conversion potential, you can unearth “hidden champions” that contribute to healthier margins without over-relying on top sellers.
Multi-dimensional product segmentation helps you uncover the hidden potential of your entire inventory based on your most critical, strategic business data.
What does this look like in action?
For example, a large retailer with 10,000+ SKUs could prioritize:
- High-margin items to drive profitability,
- Seasonal peaks (like back-to-school supplies in August),
- Inventory data to focus on products ready to sell.
By combining these dimensions, you avoid PMax’s pitfalls—like chasing quick wins while overlooking strategic opportunities. Instead, you align your campaigns with broader business goals, driving sustainable growth and a smarter ROI.
3. ROAS: Not just a performance metric, but a PMax lever
From our experience of working with over 4,000 PMax campaigns, we’ve witnessed one common misconception about ROAS. Advertisers love to look at ROAS as a proxy for campaign success, thinking the higher the ROAS, the better the results. But here’s the truth: ROAS is just an efficiency metric.
In fact, treating ROAS just as a performance indicator is one of the biggest mistakes you can make.
Why? Because ROAS is an efficiency metric—it does not necessarily correlate with your ultimate business outcomes. Whether it’s profitability of increasing your Average Order Value (AOV).
A campaign can have a high ROAS but drive low-margin sales that contribute little to your bottom line. Chasing ROAS often sacrifices opportunities for growth, like scaling high-margin products or investing in customer retention.
Reframing ROAS for growth
Many advertisers wrongfully see ROAS as an outcome. There is a glaring misunderstanding that setting target ROAS is one of the last key levers they have to steer their Performance Max campaigns to improve performance.
Here’s how to leverage ROAS:
- Set custom ROAS targets that reflect your business objectives. For example, you may set low ROAS targets and high budgets to boost strategically important products, like your top-sellers, high-margin items or products that drive Customer Lifetime Value (CLV).
- Additionally, you may set high ROAS targets and lower your budget for products that are not strategically important but can very well be advertised for high efficiency.
By treating ROAS as a lever, you can guide PMax toward outcomes that align with your broader business goals.
4. Aligning budgets with ROAS for smarter scaling
Setting the budgets and ROAS targets that perfectly align with your strategy go hand-in-hand. While multi-dimensional segmentation teaches PMax what to focus on, while your target ROAS and budget strategy determines how efficiently you can scale.
Why budget allocation matters
ROAS without budget alignment is like setting a destination without planning the route. Misaligned budgets can restrict growth opportunities, overinvest in campaigns with limited returns, or fail to maximize high-performing segments.
Dynamic budget allocation ensures PMax delivers both profitability and growth:
- Scale proven winners by increasing budgets for high-performing segments or products.
- Invest in growth by allocating flexible budgets to high-margin products, loyalty-building campaigns, or customer acquisition.
Beyond easy wins: Setting the right ROAS targets and budgets per campaign will make PMax contribute directly towards your bottom line.
5. Real-world success: How brands are using PMax strategically
Take a page out of THG’s playbook to see how aligning campaigns with more profit-driving strategies will help you hit your lucrative business goals – and not just ROAS targets.
THG’s LOOKFANTASTIC store, a leading online beauty retailer, faced tough challenges when aiming to align Performance Max campaigns with their business goal to drive sustainable profitability.
We helped them steer PMax’s ROAS targets strategically towards promoting their high-margin products and articles with the highest impact on sustainable business growth.
This resulted in
- +39% increase in daily revenue in key markets like Germany
- +42% revenue boost for several beauty shops in THG’s network
6. Building a smarter playbook for growth
To wrap up, here’s how to turn the insights from this guide into actionable steps for your campaigns:
Step 1: Segment smarter
Go beyond basic metrics like clicks and conversions, or simple, 1-dimensional approaches that neglect the complexities of the ecommerce reality. Feed PMax with multi-dimensional data that reflects your priorities, such as profit margins, seasonality, and customer loyalty.
Step 2: Stop treating ROAS as a metric
ROAS is not just a performance metric. Use it also as a lever to influence PMax’s focus. Custom targets should reflect your goals—profitability, customer acquisition, or retention—not a single-minded focus on efficiency.
Step 3: Balance budgets strategically
Pair ROAS targets with dynamic budget allocation to reach your business goals in the most efficient and effective way. That means investing in the products that matter to your business and allocate flexible budgets to products that support efficient ecommerce growth.
Conclusion: Steer, don’t chase
Google Performance Max is a game-changer for advertisers—but it doesn’t work on autopilot. To unlock its full potential, you need to steer it with the right inputs. Reimagine ROAS as a lever, implement smarter segmentation, and balance budgets to align PMax with your business goals.
smec helps businesses navigate the complexities of AI-driven platforms like PMax. If you are ready to transform PMax into your ultimate growth engine, join their masterclass, visit them at their booth at E-commerce Berlin Expo 2025 or reach out to them anytime!
***
